PRO
CON
Keep mouse pressed on the navigation icons for fast movement.
Click on a node to load that Statement.

Tentatively
REFUTED

TruthSift Answers Your Questions by Rating as tentatively established those Statements that have a proof for which all rebuttals have been answered, like this one, and their demonstrations.
By: Eric, on 11 Jan 2016

TruthSift Answers Your Questions by  rating Statements  as Tentatively Established  when they have a tentatively established proof for which all proposed refutations have been refuted., and  Giving their demonstrations. You can not only see which statements have demonstrations, but trace backward in the Diagram to find the Demonstration, and to see how challenges have been refuted.

At a given time, the status may be recently changed by an incorrect challenge. The answer may be more reliable if there have been many views since the last status change. The history of topic-statement status changes and number of member-views per status is displayed by clicking the "Views" link on the home page.


1354 Views 
Proofs (2) - PRO To Topic
Legend:  (incoming replies) , Created On, Title, Last Updated On
Refutations (2) - CON TO Topic
Legend:  (incoming replies) , Created On, Title, Last Updated On
Proofs (15) - PRO To Topic
Legend:  (incoming replies) , Created On, Title, Last Updated On
Refutations (8) - CON To Topic
Legend:  (incoming replies) , Created On, Title, Last Updated On
Responses: 23
Views: 11039
Authors: 2
Graph Last Updated: 16 Nov 2018
Topic Statement Status Last Changed: 04 Oct 2016
Node Title
Author
TruthSift Answers Your Questions by Rating as tentatively established those Statements that have a proof for which all rebuttals have been answered, like this one, and their demonstrations.

Last Updated: 05 Oct 2018
Have edited the topic statement to address point that at any given time, recent challenge could disrupt

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Moronic Challenges Can be counter-challenged. To the extent you have reason to believe the diagram has been vetted, you may have confidence

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Rightclick on statements to add challenges, proofs, assumptions, tests, and take other actions

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Only post statements you believe are valid, except to pedagogically post both statement and its debunking challenge.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
TruthSift will lead to wrong answers because anybody can change the result, not just those with degrees and positions

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
There is a defensible demonstration or the elite have no rational basis. The diagram publishes it, or highlights its non-existence.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
How do I know a statement with bold borders is correct? How do I know a challenge without bold borders like this one has been answered?

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Because if a statement has bold border, every challenge to it or its demonstration has been met with a TE counter challenge like this one

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
A statement is bold, Tentatively Established, if all of its assumptions and at least one of its proofs are TE, and no challenge is.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Doesn't it just come down to who challenges last then?

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
No, because you must post a novel reason you believe is valid when you challenge. The last valid reason wins, as it should.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
"Science is the belief in the ignorance of experts"--R.P. Feynman

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Any smart person in the world can contribute, pasting his idea right where its relevant. The system immediately highlights its impact.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
If this statement is TE, since anybody in the world can post challenges, nobody has a rational argument against it or its demonstration.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
TruthSift will yield wrong answers

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Note this Challenge Statement is Refuted because its only proofs are all Refuted

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Rationality is a property of the demonstration, not the author.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
A Bold bordered statement has a demonstration for which every challenge has been refuted.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
After everybody has made every argument and counter argument they conceive, what remains is a rational analysis of what is understood.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Challenges can be novel, but patently false.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
Any stupid person in the world can contribute, pasting his idea right where its relevant. The system immediately highlights its impact.

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016
A "New" status or something similar could help with this

Last Updated: 28 Sep 2016