PRO
CON
Keep mouse pressed on the navigation icons for fast movement.
Click on a node to load that Statement.

Tentatively
REFUTED

PROOF: The cited figures are highly significant.
By: Eric, on 09 Oct 2018

From the http://www.cfhi-fcass.ca/sf-docs/default-source/reports/risk-analytica.pdf  figure 4 p23, 45 out 100 girls in the age group make an ED visit per year. Here we have 1/10 in 42 days, which is a rate of 87 per year, nearly twice as much. 

Using the normal background rate of .45/year, we would have expected about .45*195,270*42/365 = 10,111 ED visits, but 19,351 were observed. That's an excess of 9,240 ED visits. 
The standard deviation for this number of people can be computed as sqrt(Np(1-p)) for p the probability of making an ED visit in the background, in this case .45*42/365. It is 98. That means the number of ED visits observed was about 9240/98 = 94 standard deviations in excess of the expected. In other words, the event was highly highly significant and the vaccine most likely causally connected unless there is some other systematic bias.


24 Views since Rating Change   24 Views 
Proofs (0) - CON To Topic
Legend:  (incoming replies) , Created On, Title, Last Updated On
Refutations (1) - PRO TO Topic
Legend:  (incoming replies) , Created On, Title, Last Updated On
Proofs (42) - PRO To Topic
Legend:  (incoming replies) , Created On, Title, Last Updated On
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
    11 Jan 2016 Aluminum Load is Safe 07 Dec 2018
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
    11 Jan 2016 Mitkus et al showed its safe 07 Dec 2018
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TE    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TE    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
    22 Feb 2016 Reliability of animal data 07 Dec 2018
  • TR    0
    28 Feb 2016 The Thimerisol isn't causing autism 07 Dec 2018
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
    08 Aug 2016 HPV dosage procedure 07 Dec 2018
  • TE    0
    08 Aug 2016 ED visit rates 07 Dec 2018
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TR    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
    09 Oct 2018 I stand corrected 07 Dec 2018
  • TR    0
Refutations (107) - CON To Topic
Legend:  (incoming replies) , Created On, Title, Last Updated On
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TR    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TR    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
    20 Jun 2016 Cargo Cult Science 07 Dec 2018
  • TE    0
  • TR    0
  • TE    0
    10 Aug 2016 This is false 07 Dec 2018
  • TR    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TR    0
  • TR    0
  •    0
    14 Aug 2018 [deleted by author] 07 Dec 2018
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
    04 Oct 2018 This is false 07 Dec 2018
  • TR    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
  • TE    0
Responses: 150
Views: 55974
Authors: 5
Graph Last Updated: 21 Mar 2019
Topic Statement Status Last Changed: 10 Aug 2016